Jay-Z went looking for the perfect gift for his wife Beyoncé to celebrate the couple’s fourth wedding anniversary today. Blue Ivy’s father was all smiles as he visited Jacob Arabo’s jewelry store in Manhattan, chatting with the jeweler outside as the paparazzi snapped away. He left empty-handed, but we’re sure Jay has a few surprises up his sleeve. Congrats to Mr. and Mrs. Carter on four years of marriage